<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">

WHEN LEADERSHIP CREATES CRISIS: INTERNAL CRISIS COMMUNICATION, CRISIS LEADERSHIP, AND RELIABILITY IN U.S. FEDERAL SCIENCE AGENCIES

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Files

MattasCurry_umd_0117E_26439.pdf (2.52 MB) (RESTRICTED ACCESS)
No. of downloads:

Publication or External Link

External Link to Data Files

Date

Advisor

Fisher Liu, Brooke

Citation

Abstract

While high-reliability organization (HRO) theory documents how organizations build and maintain reliability, it has not theorized how reliability is deliberately dismantled. Similarly, internal crisis communication (ICC) and crisis leadership (CL) scholarship assume leaders function as sensegivers whose authentic communication enables organizational recovery. This assumption becomes particularly salient for public relations professionals who occupy central roles in designing and managing communication infrastructure during institutional crises. This research examines what happens when those assumptions no longer hold, for example when institutional contexts become actively hostile to the conditions enabling reliability, and when communication systems—the very infrastructure that public relations professionalsmanage and depend upon—are repurposed as instruments of coercion rather than deployed to foster understanding.

This research employed semi-structured interviews with 34 participants across six U.S. federal science agencies (the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC); the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA); the U.S. Food and DrugAdministration (FDA); the National Institutes of Health (NIH); the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA); and the United States Geological Survey (USGS) at three organizational levels (Senior Executive Service, manager, and frontline staff). Participants described organizational functioning before January 2025, the systematic dismantling that followed, and how employees adapted when institutions failed. Prior to the crisis, these agencies demonstrated genuine high- reliability functioning at the local levels, grounded in mission-driven cultures where employees had deliberately built their careers around organizational missions, psychological safety, and caring identities. Following January 2025, reliability was dismantled through coordinated attacks on scientific judgment, operational capacity, meaningful missions, psychological safety, and communication infrastructure. When official communication was turned against its own purpose, employees constructed alternative networks—encrypted Signal chats, Reddit communities, union networks, and peer relationships—demonstrating secure digital resistance. These informal adaptations sustained individual psychological resilience but could not repair formal institutional failure or restore organizational capacity.

The research reveals a critical asymmetry central to understanding institutional crisis: While people found remarkable capacity for informal adaptation and psychological resilience, this adaptation could not restore institutionalfunctioning, especially at the local levels, once structural conditions enabling reliability had been destroyed. The findings extend HRO, internal crisis communication, and crisis leadership theories by documenting HRO deconstruction as a distinct theorizable process and introducing institutional deconstruction as a framework for understanding internally generated organizational crisis.

For public relations scholars and professionals, this research clarifies that protecting organizational reliability requires more than crisis communication expertise—it requires understanding how communication infrastructure can be co-opted forcontrol, how to build resilient and distributed communication systems resistant to hijacking, and how to protect relational and ethical foundations of authentic communication. The findings demonstrate that organizational reliability depends on protecting the structural and relational conditions through which people construct meaningful professional identities and the reciprocal care relationships through which they commit to missions serving the public good.

Notes

Rights

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By