What I Saw There Is Burned In My Memory: Hard War in the Civil War Shenandoah Valley and Its Legacies
Files
Publication or External Link
External Link to Data Files
Date
Authors
Advisor
Citation
DRUM DOI
Abstract
In the summer and fall of 1864, the Union armies of generals David Hunterand Philip Sheridan burned and confiscated the property of thousands of families in Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley in order to destroy the region’s capacity to support Confederate forces. These devastations severely traumatized the people of the region and became known simply as “The Burning.” This dissertation examines the nature and effects of the destructive “hard war” campaigns in the Valley, tracing the development of collective memory about them through subsequent American history. It uncouples Hunter’s and Sheridan’s devastations from General William T. Sherman’s March through Georgia, events that are often conflated in both motive and method. It explores how the collective memory of the burning of the Shenandoah Valley developed in the context of postwar trends in Civil War memory, including the South’s “Lost Cause” ideology and the process of sectional reconciliation between North and South. The contested memory of The Burning reveals deep divisions over Civil War memory that persisted long after national reconciliation is often assumed to have been achieved. As the United States and Europe embarked on wars of empire in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, memories of the destruction in the Shenandoah Valley were invoked in arguments over the nature of “civilized” warfare. The Burning in the Shenandoah Valley faded in collective memory during the twentieth century even as the contemporaneous depredations of General Sherman in Georgia endured as one of the Civil War’s primary cultural touchstones. This dissertation argues that the very different nature of the populations of these two regions is key to understanding why one event is far better remembered today.
Drawing from military records, newspapers, letters and diaries, works of localhistory, and school textbooks, this study explores the nature of The Burning in its historical context, as well as the formation, transmission, and uses of its memory in regional and national discourse. The terrible events in the Shenandoah Valley in 1864 provide a lens that illuminates how Americans have dealt with the more discomforting aspects of Civil War memory and reveals developing attitudes about the morality of turning civilians into military targets.