<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">

THERE’S NO PILL FOR WHAT AILS US: PARANOIA, POWER, AND THE POLITICS OF PREVENTION

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Files

Betts_umd_0117E_26482.pdf (1.57 MB) (RESTRICTED ACCESS)
No. of downloads:

Publication or External Link

External Link to Data Files

Date

Advisor

Bruce, La Marr Jurelle

Citation

Abstract

There’s No Pill for What Ails Us: Paranoia, Power, and the Politics of Prevention explores how paranoia influences the health decisions Black Americans make by focusing on Black women’s mistrust of prescription birth control in relation to Black queer men’s mistrust of and pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP). I theorize Black paranoia as a historically produced interpretive orientation shaped by racialized, gendered, and heteronormative vulnerability, rather than as a clinical diagnosis or irrationality. Drawing on queer of color critique, Black feminist theory, and mad methodology, I argue that paranoia operates across three overlapping registers: as an effect of living under conditions of anticipated harm, as an epistemology for evaluating knowledge and risk under uncertainty, and as an ideological critique that exposes the contradictions of biomedical authority and narratives of medical progress.

Methodologically, this project treats rumors, skepticism, hesitation, and narratives of medical distrust not as misinformation requiring correction, but as forms of knowledge production through which Black Americans negotiate power, care, and vulnerability under conditions of hegemonic uncertainty. To explore these dynamics, I employ a qualitative mixed-methods approach combining genealogical and historiographic methods, critical discourse and rhetorical analysis, cultural criticism, Critical Technocultural Discourse analysis, and semi-structured focus groups and interviews. Through these modes of analysis, I examine Black women's concerns about birth control, Black queer men's perceptions of and refusals of PrEP, Black holistic health discourse, and healthcare content circulating on social media. Rather than treating these phenomena as discrete contemporary issues, I trace how historical narratives about Black bodies, medical authority, risk, sexuality, and prevention continue to shape present-day forms of healthcare paranoia.

Taken together, I argue that Black paranoia is not simply a deficit to be corrected or a pathology to be explained away. Rather, it is a productive and contested mode of sense-making that reveals how Black communities navigate uncertainty, institutional power, and uneven distributions of vulnerability in contemporary healthcare systems. By centering paranoia as an analytic framework, this project rethinks the relationship between knowledge, trust, and power in Black health worlds and demonstrates how refusal, suspicion, and critique can function as forms of epistemic practice.

Notes

Rights

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By