<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">

THE AUTHENTIC/ATED SUBJECT: GENETIC ANCESTRY TESTING, IDEOLOGY, AND CARIBBEAN EXISTENTIALISM

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Files

AsgaraliHoffman_umd_0117E_26507.pdf (1.58 MB) (RESTRICTED ACCESS)
No. of downloads:

Publication or External Link

External Link to Data Files

Date

Advisor

Erete, Sheena

Citation

Abstract

While race scholars have critiqued the problem of racial reinscription via genetic ancestry testing, likening the process to those of its eugenic predecessors, I approach this reinscription by critiquing genetic ancestry testing not simply as an attempt at biological essentialism, but as an act of algorithmic essentialism. In this work I employ cultural studies methods to three case studies to demonstrate multiple layers of ideological construction by the genetic ancestry testing industry, focusing on the two largest direct-to-consumer genetic ancestry testing companies: 23andMe and AncestryDNA. I find that these companies, as part of a broader Big Tech apparatus, employ technoracial capitalist and neoliberal ideologies to redefine and commodify the concept of personal authenticity.

In study one, I conduct an ideological analysis of interviews with direct-to-consumer genetic ancestry testing company founders and video commercials created by ancestry testing companies. I draw on Louis Althusser’s concept of the ideological subject to reveal the ideologies embedded in the messaging of the genetic ancestry testing industry. I demonstrate how this industry constructs “the authentic/ated subject,” a subject that can only be made “real” or “authentic” by subjecting themselves to processes of authentication. In study two, I juxtapose YouTube content created in partnership between the industry and social media entertainment channels, and between the industry and independent filmmakers. This study further demonstrates the conflation of authenticity and authentication, yielding enmeshed ontological and epistemic implications that affect how consumers understand their identity. I also tease out moments of ideological struggle in creative independent filmmaking about genetic ancestry testing. In study three, I analyze YouTube genetic ancestry test “reveal videos” made by individual Caribbean consumers. I demonstrate how a Caribbean epistemology is employed in ideological struggle against a flattened neoliberal understanding of authenticity. Throughout this dissertation, I use Caribbean existentialism as a framework for critiquing our current understanding of authenticity, illuminating how a way of knowing the world marked by destabilization is key in destabilizing the foundation upon which the authentic/ated subject is built.

Notes

Rights

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By