Adult discrimination of children’s voices over time: Voice discrimination of auditory samples from longitudinal research studies

Abstract

The human voice is subject to change over the lifespan, and these changes are even more pronounced in children. Acoustic properties of speech, such as fundamental frequency, amplitude, speech rate, and fluency, change dramatically as children grow and develop (Lee et al., 1999). Previous studies have established that listeners have a generally strong capacity to discriminate between adult speakers, as well as identify the age of a speaker, based solely on the voice (Kreiman and Sidtis, 2011; Park, 2019). However, few studies have been performed on the listener’s capacity to discriminate between the voices of children, particularly as the voice matures over time.

This study examines how well adult listeners can discriminate between the voices of young children of the same age and at different ages. Single-word child language samples from different children (N = 6) were obtained from Munson et al. (2021) and used to create closed-set online AX voice discrimination tasks for adult listeners (N= 31). Three tasks examined listeners’ accuracy and sensitivity in identifying whether a voice was that of the same child or a different child under three conditions: 1) between two children that are both three-years old, 2) between two children that are five-years old, and 3) between two children of different ages (three- vs. five-years old).

Listeners’ performance showed above-chance levels of accuracy and sensitivity at discriminating between the voices of children at three-years-old and at two children at five-years-old. Listener performance was not significantly different in these two tasks. No listeners demonstrated above-chance levels of accuracy in discriminating between the voices of a single child at two different ages. Listener performance was significantly poorer in this task compared to the previous two. The findings from this experiment demonstrated a sizable difference in adults' ability to recognize child voices at two different ages than at one age. Possible explanations and implications for understanding child talker discrimination across different ages are discussed.