Show simple item record

GRICEAN EFFECTS IN SELF-ADMINSTERED SURVEYS

dc.contributor.advisorTourangeau, Rogeren_US
dc.contributor.authorYan, Tingen_US
dc.date.accessioned2006-02-04T06:45:05Z
dc.date.available2006-02-04T06:45:05Z
dc.date.issued2005-10-31en_US
dc.identifier.urihttp://hdl.handle.net/1903/3080
dc.description.abstractDespite the best efforts of questionnaire designers, survey respondents don't always interpret questions as the question writers intended. Researchers have used Grice's conversational maxims to explain some of these discrepancies. This dissertation extends this work by reviewing studies on the use of Grice's maxims by survey respondents and describing six new experiments that looked for direct evidence that respondents apply Grice's maxims. The strongest evidence for respondents' use of the maxims came from an experiment that varied the numerical labels on a rating scale; the mean shift in responses to the right side of the rating scale induced by negative numerical labels was robust across items and fonts. Process measures indicated that respondents applied the maxim of relation in interpreting the questions. Other evidence supported use of the maxim of quantity -- as predicted, correlations between two highly similar items were lower when they were asked together. Reversing the wording of one of the items didn't prevent respondents from applying the maxim of quantity. Evidence was weaker for the application of Grice's maxim of manner; respondents still seemed to use definitions (as was apparent from the reduced variation in their answers), even though the definitions were designed to be uninformative. That direct questions without filters induced significantly more responses on the upper end of the scale -- presumably because of the presuppositions direct questions carried -- supported respondents' application of the maxim of quality. There was little support for respondents' use of the maxim of relation from an experiment on the physical layout of survey questions; the three different layouts didn't influence how respondents perceived the relation among items. These results provided some evidence that both survey "satisficers" and survey "optimizers" may draw automatic inferences based on Gricean maxims, but that only "optimizers" will carry out the more controlled processes requiring extra effort. Practical implications for survey practice include the need for continued attention to secondary features of survey questions in addition to traditional questionnaire development issues. Additional experiments that incorporate other techniques such as eye tracking or cognitive interviews may help to uncover other subtle mechanisms affecting survey responses.en_US
dc.format.extent1326521 bytes
dc.format.mimetypeapplication/pdf
dc.language.isoen_US
dc.titleGRICEAN EFFECTS IN SELF-ADMINSTERED SURVEYSen_US
dc.typeDissertationen_US
dc.contributor.publisherDigital Repository at the University of Marylanden_US
dc.contributor.publisherUniversity of Maryland (College Park, Md.)en_US
dc.contributor.departmentSurvey Methodologyen_US
dc.subject.pqcontrolledStatisticsen_US
dc.subject.pquncontrolledsurvey methodologyen_US
dc.subject.pquncontrolledmeasurement erroren_US
dc.subject.pquncontrolledconversation maximsen_US


Files in this item

Thumbnail

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record